|
Since the projectors unlike TV is a native progressive device, any input interlaced signal has to be converted to progressive inside the projector. A salesman would tell you that it is better to use progressive DVD player and progressive input in projector, but in real life this may not be true.
Here is a secret the salesman doesn't even know:
Because films on DVD are stored in 24 progressive frames per second an then to keep it with the 30 fps of NTSC the normal DVD player has to apply so called 3:2 pulldown. This splits every 24fps frame into two interlaced fields (48 half frames per sec) and then add additional field for every other frame. (which adds 12 half-frames per second which gives the needed 60 half-frames or 30 full frames per second) So the result is: two fileds of one film-frame then three fields of second film-frame, then again two fields of third film-frame etc...
Obviously because of the new 3-2-3-2-3 fields the TV display some frames where even lines are from film-frame A but odd lines already from film-frame B as in the image on left marked by (2). On fast scenes or cuts (1) this may create jagginess.
That's still considered a normal knowledge even between salesmans.
Now yo would say, since a DVD film is already progressive, the progressive DVD player can just read these frames as they are without interlacing and then convert them to 29.97 fps. But, here is the secret: The progressive players don't do this. They do all the stuff with interlacing as the normal players above. What you pay your big bucks is the video processor which takes these now interlaced frames and create progressive output by again deinterlacing them. Funny, isn't it?
But with the deinterlacing you are not simply merging every two half-frames (img 2) as on TV (this will create the same jaginnes on certain frames) but you use various interpolating and scene detection techniques to determine which half frames to merge, which ignore and which to duplicate. Now obviously not every deinterlacers are build with the same logic and processing, there are bad ones, average and a good ones.
And this is the whole story. Since the home theater projectors doesn't display the picture in interlaced way, they have build-in deinterlacers. Because the bad interpolating and jaginnes would be quite visible on big screen, often they have very good deinterlacers. For example Plus Piano uses Silicon Image, which is the butter in this class.
The bottom line: The progressive DVD players do the "progressive" trick by deinterlacing the signal not by directly using progressive data from DVD. However unless you have first class (read expensive) progressive DVD player the deinterlacer in a good home theater projector (Piano) may does a better job as many of normal progressive players. Even the argument that the deinterlacing in projector is from analog signal while deinterlacing in DVD is from digital doesn't seems to affect this reality.
|